Poor Jen Lindley! Michelle Williams’ Dawson’s Creek alter ego was all kinds of tragic. It ain’t easy being Joey’s runner-up for six seasons straight, y’know?! We know it’s no consolation, Jen, but we’ve been coveting your major 90s look of late. From that signature morange lip to the before-your-time long bob (aka lob), we’d like pay tribute to four of your most excellent looks—though we’ll probably seek life advice elsewhere.